A large group that wants to launch a new activity, a new product range, a new service or a new market has three options. It can buy a company that already does it. It can build in-house, with its own teams. Or it can create a new company, outside, with entrepreneurs. All three work. None fits every situation. The choice depends on four things: the time you have, the control you want to keep, the risk you accept, and what you already own.
Buy
The fastest route when the target exists. You buy revenue, a team, a technology and a position in the market.
- When it is the right choice: the market is already structured, one company is winning it, and the group can pay the price.
- What it costs: the acquisition premium, the integration, and the risk of seeing the founders leave once their earn-out ends.
- What often fails: integration. The acquired company loses what made it fast by adopting the group's processes.
- Limit: when the market is emerging, there is often nothing to buy, or only companies too small to matter.
Build in-house
The most natural route: a team, a budget, a sponsor on the executive committee.
- When it is the right choice: the new activity is close to the core business, uses the same customers and channels, and can live with the group's rules.
- What it costs: more than people think, at the start and over time. The budget is renegotiated every year, the best people rarely stay, and the cost of the teams is often invisible.
- What often fails: pace. The group's IT, legal, procurement and pay rules slow everything down. The project lives as long as its sponsor protects it.
- Limit: an internal project does not attract entrepreneurs, and can neither raise money nor be sold.
Create outside, with entrepreneurs
This is corporate venture building: a new, independent company, created with the group rather than by it, run by entrepreneurs who own part of the capital, and built on a rare asset of the group.
- When it is the right choice: the market is new or adjacent, the group has a real advantage (distribution, data, brand, regulatory standing), and it accepts controlling a company without running it.
- What it costs: typically €5 to 15M per company over the whole build, committed in two tranches. The group holds the majority and has a buy-out option set from the start.
- What fails: a change of strategy above the company, funding renegotiated instead of committed, a casting error in the team.
- Limit: you have to be able to say no. Some projects must stop after the study phase, before any company is created.
In short
| Buy | Build in-house | Create outside | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Time to first customer | immediate | 12 to 24 months | 6 to 9 months |
| Control | full | full | majority, without running it |
| Upfront cost | very high | high | moderate, committed in two tranches |
| Entrepreneurial talent | to retain | rare | shareholders |
| Possible exit | resale | rarely | buy-out of the balance or sale |
| Main risk | integration | slowness, abandonment | group strategy, casting |
| Cost-to-own | €€€€ | €€€ | €€ |
The right question is not "which route is best", but "what do we own that nobody else has, and which route makes the most of it". When the answer is a rare asset and a market that is still open, creating outside is often the fastest way to own something new.
Further reading: launching a new business: dos, don'ts and cost-to-own.