Launching a new business inside a large group is first a series of choices: what to launch, with which lever, at what cost, and who runs it. This page brings together the questions to ask, what to do and avoid, a launch checklist, and how to work out the cost-to-own.
The right questions before you start
- Which market problem, validated by customers, do we want to attack?
- Which rare asset do we bring, that nobody can copy in six months?
- Should this business live with our rules, or would they stifle it?
- Are we ready to commit funding over several years, in two tranches?
- Who will run the company? An entrepreneur with something to lose, or a seconded employee?
- What will we do if it works: keep it, buy out the balance, sell it?
- What will we do if it does not work, and when will we know?
Do
- Study the opportunity for two months before creating anything, and accept saying no.
- Bring a pair of entrepreneurs into the capital, usually a CEO and a CTO, along with key people.
- Place the intellectual property in the new company from day one.
- Commit both funding tranches at launch, the second on written criteria.
- Set the group's buy-out option from the start: terms, price, timing.
- Write a charter of roles between the group, the entrepreneurs and the studio.
- Design a board where the group controls without being able to outvote the operators on its own.
Don't
- Mistake a successful POC for a business.
- Appoint an experienced manager instead of a founder.
- Fund drop by drop, budget by budget.
- Attach the project to a business unit and its rules.
- Let the group's strategy alone decide whether the company survives.
- Negotiate the buy-out option once the company is already worth a lot.
Launch checklist
- Problem validated through customer interviews
- Rare asset identified and made available by contract
- Formal go / no-go at the end of the study
- Company incorporated, IP held by the company
- Cap table signed (group, entrepreneurs, studio)
- Two-tranche funding approved, criteria for the second written down
- Buy-out option set
- Charter of roles signed
- Board formed, with an independent member
- First checkpoint dated
Before choosing a lever: a thesis
A new business is not decided project by project. You start from the group's strategic plan and, as a fund would with its investment thesis, you write an innovation thesis: what are the two to four subjects the group absolutely must master, to the point that not leading on them would be a major strategic risk? These subjects are approved by the CEO. Better to excel on two to four themes than do a bit of everything.
For each subject, you then choose the right lever and the matching objective:
- Partnering with startups: fast and cheap, but little control and limited business impact.
- Building in-house: mobilises the teams, with a lot of inertia. Suited to new features, much less to new businesses.
- Building with a venture studio: a new company created with entrepreneurs, combining the group's strengths with entrepreneurial agility. Spinning off an early activity or buying an asset to move faster can also make sense.
- Buying: a minority stake is more a financial bet than a strategic one. A full acquisition can close a gap on a market or a technology, often at a high price, and integration remains the critical point.
Cost-to-own
This is when you work out the cost-to-own: what does it cost, over time, to master this new business? Not only the entry ticket, but everything you pay to own a business that works: upfront costs, operating costs, integration costs, set against expected revenue, the ability to scale and the risk taken.
| Criterion | In-house innovation | Acquisition | Consultants | Venture studio |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Upfront costs | high | very high | high | moderate |
| Operating costs | high | high | low | moderate |
| Integration costs | low | high | low | moderate |
| Savings achieved | medium | low | low | high |
| Revenue generated | long term | immediate | medium term | medium term |
| Ability to scale | low | high | low | high |
| Risk taken | medium | high | low | medium |
| Cost-to-own | €€€ | €€€€ | €€€ | €€ |
The exercise helps you choose between levers, subject by subject. To choose is to give something up.
A three-year budget
A new business takes time, carries risk and needs the means to match its ambitions. The choices made subject by subject translate into a three-year budget, a clear roadmap and measurable KPIs.
Further reading: buy, build in-house or create outside with entrepreneurs.